• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

ABOUT US RESOURCES TESTIMONIALS BLOG CONTACT US

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Find Your State
  • Find Your Specialty
  • Choose a Facility
  • Resources
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Request A Quote

Are Caps on Non-Economic Damages a Thing of the Past?

April 4, 2014

On Thursday, March 13th, Florida became the latest in a growing list of states whose supreme courts have struck down caps on non-economic damages.  In Florida’s case the court argued in a 5-2 ruling that the caps “arbitrarily” and “illogically” limited damages, particularly in cases where there are multiple claimants.  The court found that by having a single cap irrespective of the number of claimants, thus reducing the amount each claimant could receive in a multiple claimant case, the provision violated the equal protection clause of the Florida Constitution.  The court also cited other states that had ruled similarly and offered some pushback to the arguments that caps are necessary to prevent runaway juries and skyrocketing malpractice insurance premiums.

As noted, Florida is the latest in what is getting to be a long list of states where the court has overturned caps on non-economic damage awards (i.e. pain and suffering).  Illinois, New Hampshire, Missouri, Georgia, and others have seen similar decisions.  A few states have re-written laws capping damages after a court overturn of an initial version, including Texas, Kansas, Ohio and Wisconsin.  But for other states like, Kentucky, Arizona, Pennsylvania, and Wyoming, caps are explicitly forbidden in the language of their state constitutions.  The trend definitely seems to be toward states moving away from these caps on non-economic damages.

Strangely, while the logic of how caps should keep malpractice insurance premiums down is fairly straightforward, we haven’t seen huge spikes in premiums in most states where they have been overturned.  There are several possible explanations for this.  It could just be that not enough time has elapsed yet.  Malpractice claims are notorious for dragging on, sometimes for years, and then there is the appeals process.  It’s possible that in a few years, as cases that are being filed now begin to wrap up, these states that are removing the caps will see rates start to soar again.

On the other hand, it’s also possible that the market is just in a good spot right now for rates to remain steady and relatively low.  But why might that be?  Well, in many of these states non-economic damage caps were put in place roughly a decade ago in the midst of very turbulent malpractice markets, skyrocketing premiums, and in some cases, like Florida and Missouri, a doctor shortage crisis.  One can speculate that the caps, which usually formed part of a broader tort reform package, along with the development and founding of new insurance companies in the suddenly more stable markets where risk could be assessed more accurately, created the conditions we enjoy now.  In other words, it seems likely that these caps, along with other reform elements that remain in effect, did work, and did bring stability and competition back to the market.

However, saying that they worked doesn’t necessarily entail that when they are overturned everything will return to the way it was before they were enacted.  It may be that they created the space for a stable and competitive market to develop, and that now, even if/when they go away, the increased number of providers, and thus competition remains.  This doesn’t mean we’re happy to see caps overturned, we think it’s risky considering the way things were in many states prior to enacting them.  But we are cautiously optimistic.  Hopefully the markets are stable and competitive enough now that removing one of the elements that brought order won’t lead to chaos or collapse.

If you are looking for malpractice insurance be sure and check out our Get a Quote page.  eQuoteMD can put you in contact with someone that will shop the market and find you the best policy at the best value available no matter what your specialty or what state you practice in.  We’re glad to help you find the coverage you need.  You can also call us at 1 (855) 857-8746 or email us at info@equotemd.com with any questions you have.

This post was written by Justin Donathan.
Justin at Google+

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Primary Sidebar

Calendar

April 2014
M T W T F S S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930  
« Mar   May »

Categories

  • Ask eQuoteMD
  • General
  • Malpractice Insurance
  • Malpractice Insurance Coverage
  • Medical Liability Insurance
  • Medical Malpractice
  • medical malpractice insurance
  • medical malpractice lawsuit
  • OB/GYN
  • tail coverage
  • Telehealth
  • Uncategorized

Tags

Affordable Medical Malpractice Insurance best malpractice insurance California claims made coverage damage caps defensive medicine doctors liability insurance group medical malpractice insurance hipaa individual medical malpractice insurance judicial legal legislation liability malpractice malpractice insurance Malpractice Insurance Coverage malpractice insurance for doctors Malpractice Insurance near me malpractice insurance quote medical liability insurance medical malpractice medical malpractice coverage medical malpractice insurance medical malpractice insurance broker medical malpractice insurance companies medical malpractice insurance company Medical Malpractice Insurance for Family Medicine Medical Malpractice Insurance provider medical malpractice insurance providers medical malpractice lawsuit medical professional liability insurance news non-economic damages occurrence physician malpractice insurance policy professional medical liability insurance research study tail tail coverage technology tort reform

Footer

eQuoteMD

BLOG

Integris Group logo

The legal elements involved in a medical malpractice case include: Legal duty Breach of that READ MORE

Doctor And Nurse Suture Patient In Emergency Room

As a physician, you are no doubt aware of the importance of having malpractice insurance to protect READ MORE

Pregnant woman lying down on a hospital bed and talking to a doctor

“Medical Malpractice Insurance policies have become a commodity in the insurance industry, meaning READ MORE

FIND YOUR STATE FIND YOUR SPECIALTY CHOOSE A FACILITY

ABOUT US RESOURCES TESTIMONIALS BLOG CONTACT US

HOME ADA DISCLAIMER PRIVACY POLICY SITEMAP

Copyright © 2023 · eQuoteMD · All Rights Reserved

iHealthspot Medical Website Design and Medical Marketing by iHealthSpot.com

eQuoteMD provides medical malpractice insurance services in all states for all specialties.