• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

ABOUT US RESOURCES TESTIMONIALS BLOG CONTACT US

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Find Your State
  • Find Your Specialty
  • Choose a Facility
  • Resources
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Request A Quote

Coexistence of Risk Retention Groups and Admitted Carriers in New York

November 9, 2011

Part 1: Thoughts on the Types of Med Mal Carriers for an Introspective Insured

If you have spent any time dealing with medical malpractice insurance in New York state, you know two things:

  • First, New York is home to some of the most obscenely expensive medical professional liability insurance in the country.
  • Second, there is a politically charged, financially driven battle waging for dominance over the medical malpractice insurance market in the state.

Doctors in New York have experienced some of the highest medical malpractice insurance premiums in the country for years, with some specialty classes paying upwards of a quarter million dollars for a solo doctor. Until several years ago, doctors had two main options; the admitted carriers MLMIC and PRI.

 

Doctors who could not obtain coverage with either of these companies were obligated to obtain coverage in the state’s insurance pool, MMIP due to the fact that excess and surplus lines carriers are, aside from a small loophole, not allowed to sell policies in New York.

Opportunities for Medical Malpractice Insurance in New York

Seeing an opportunity, Risk Retention Groups (RRG’s) started moving into the state of New York in the early 2000’s.  Risk Retention Groups are governed under federal statutes, not state regulations. Ergo with a single state of domicile, they can write policies in any state they choose without being technically “admitted” in a state.  However, without being a “state admitted carrier” RRG’s are unable to tap into a state’s insurance guarantee fund, which would normally partially subsidize the obligations of a failed or insolvent admitted carrier.

In New York’s case, MLMIC and PRI are the only carriers that have access to the guarantee fund. However the term “guarantee” may be considered misleading in a situation where the guarantor is financially upside-down.  The 2011/2012 New York state budget projects a deficit of more than $8.2 billion.  Some have suggested that the failure of either of the admitted carriers would ultimately drain the guarantee fund to the point where its obligations to doctors could not be met.

New York Doctors Can Find Relief

Seeking relief from high New York medical malpractice insurance premiums many doctors over the last several years have been moving to the RRG market.  RRG’s operate in a similar fashion as a mutual company where the doctors are part owners of the insurance company.  As opposed to the company trying to stay solvent while also attempting to earn a profit for investors from the doctor’s premiums, RRG’s price their products solely to stay fiscally sound.  Since the owners of the company are doctors and there are fewer investors or non-physician shareholders to pay, the goal of the company becomes exclusively focused on sustainably low premiums.

Ultimately this translates into a premium savings of 15%-25% from New York’s admitted carrier rates.  This savings is obviously attractive to the doctors who have been weighed down for years by the high costs of coverage in New York.

Final Thoughts

Due to additional layers of complexity drawn from a dynamic political landscape carved by elected officials, hospitals, and the carriers posturing for position in New York, there is no blanket answer as to which type of carrier is better for a doctor.  Each specific medical practice requires a review of several current factors and potential future decisions.  Such a review could translate into an opportunity for a doctor to save tens of thousands of dollars on his or her coverage or serve to reinforce the decision to stay with a specific type of carrier.  Finding an impartial expert who is well seasoned in the New York medical malpractice insurance market is the first step in determining the proper course of action.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Primary Sidebar

Calendar

November 2011
M T W T F S S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930  
« Oct   Dec »

Categories

  • Ask eQuoteMD
  • General
  • Malpractice Insurance
  • Malpractice Insurance Coverage
  • Medical Liability Insurance
  • Medical Malpractice
  • medical malpractice insurance
  • medical malpractice lawsuit
  • OB/GYN
  • tail coverage
  • Telehealth
  • Uncategorized

Tags

Affordable Medical Malpractice Insurance best malpractice insurance California claims made coverage damage caps defensive medicine doctors liability insurance group medical malpractice insurance hipaa individual medical malpractice insurance judicial legal legislation liability malpractice malpractice insurance Malpractice Insurance Coverage malpractice insurance for doctors Malpractice Insurance near me malpractice insurance quote medical liability insurance medical malpractice medical malpractice coverage medical malpractice insurance medical malpractice insurance broker medical malpractice insurance companies medical malpractice insurance company Medical Malpractice Insurance for Family Medicine Medical Malpractice Insurance provider medical malpractice insurance providers medical malpractice lawsuit medical professional liability insurance news non-economic damages occurrence physician malpractice insurance policy professional medical liability insurance research study tail tail coverage technology tort reform

Footer

eQuoteMD

BLOG

Integris Group logo

The legal elements involved in a medical malpractice case include: Legal duty Breach of that READ MORE

Doctor And Nurse Suture Patient In Emergency Room

As a physician, you are no doubt aware of the importance of having malpractice insurance to protect READ MORE

Pregnant woman lying down on a hospital bed and talking to a doctor

“Medical Malpractice Insurance policies have become a commodity in the insurance industry, meaning READ MORE

FIND YOUR STATE FIND YOUR SPECIALTY CHOOSE A FACILITY

ABOUT US RESOURCES TESTIMONIALS BLOG CONTACT US

HOME ADA DISCLAIMER PRIVACY POLICY SITEMAP

Copyright © 2023 · eQuoteMD · All Rights Reserved

iHealthspot Medical Website Design and Medical Marketing by iHealthSpot.com

eQuoteMD provides medical malpractice insurance services in all states for all specialties.